1Department of Occupational Therapy, Hana General Hospital, Cheongju, Korea
2Department of Occupational Therapy, College of Health and Medical Sciences, Cheongju University, Cheongju, Korea
© 2021 Korea Disease Control and Prevention Agency
This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Ethics Approval
This study was approved by the Institutional Review Board (IRB) from the Cheongju University (IRB No: 1041107-202006-HR-031-01). Written informed consent was obtained from the subject before the intervention.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.
Funding
None.
Availability of Data
The datasets are not publicly available but are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
Additional Contributions
The authors would like to express their appreciation to all the participants and their families for their cooperation and participation in this study.
Variable |
Intervention with groups |
Difference between groups |
|||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Before (mean±SD) | After (mean±SD) | Z | p | Mean±SD | Z | p | |
Upper extremity training | |||||||
EG | 14.40±1.35 | 15.53±0.74 | –2.724 | 0.006** | 1.13±1.18 | –0.932 | 0.351 |
CG | 14.40±1.45 | 15.20±1.01 | –2.414 | 0.016* | 0.80±1.14 | ||
Grip strength | |||||||
EG | 5.33±0.48 | 5.87±0.35 | –2.530 | 0.011* | 0.67±0.48 | –2.159 | 0.031* |
CG | 5.47±0.51 | 5.73±0.45 | –2.000 | 0.046* | 0.27±0.45 | ||
Finger manipulation | |||||||
EG | 4.60±0.91 | 6.20±1.08 | –3.520 | 0.000** | 1.60±0.50 | –2.361 | 0.018* |
CG | 4.60±0.82 | 5.53±0.99 | –2.889 | 0.004** | 0.93±0.79 | ||
Total score | |||||||
EG | 24.53±1.99 | 27.73±1.58 | –3.438 | 0.001** | 3.20±1.52 | –2.430 | 0.015* |
CG | 24.47±2.06 | 26.40±1.95 | –3.088 | 0.002** | 1.93±1.79 |
Variable |
Intervention with groups |
Difference between groups |
|||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Before (mean±SD) | After (mean±SD) | Z | p | Mean±SD | Z | p | |
DST-Forward | |||||||
EG | 5.27±0.88 | 6.93±0.88 | –3.542 | 0.000** | 1.67±0.48 | –3.181 | 0.001** |
CG | 5.20±1.08 | 6.07±1.10 | –3.127 | 0.002** | 0.87±0.64 | ||
DST-Backward | |||||||
EG | 2.60±0.73 | 3.93±0.45 | –3.397 | 0.001** | 1.33±0.61 | –3.500 | 0.000** |
CG | 3.00±0.75 | 3.40±0.73 | –2.449 | 0.0141* | 0.40±0.50 | ||
EFPT-K | |||||||
EG | 12.70±2.51 | 9.96±1.30 | –3.413 | 0.001** | –2.74±1.29 | –4.720 | 0.000** |
CG | 12.70±2.63 | 11.94±2.58 | –3.474 | 0.001** | –0.77±0.19 | ||
K-TMT-e B | |||||||
EG | 89.13±10.85 | 67.00±12.16 | –3.411 | 0.001** | –22.13±4.86 | –3.199 | 0.001** |
CG | 89.60±12.33 | 77.00±13.26 | –3.412 | 0.001** | –12.60±7.83 |
Variable |
Intervention with groups |
Difference between groups |
|||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Before (mean±SD) | After (mean±SD) | Z | p | Mean±SD | Z | p | |
Physical health | |||||||
EG | 19.47±3.50 | 26.00±2.59 | –3.391 | 0.001** | 6.53±2.61 | –3.158 | 0.002** |
CG | 19.93±4.14 | 23.60±4.18 | –3.309 | 0.001** | 3.67±2.09 | ||
Psychology | |||||||
EG | 15.60±2.44 | 22.33±3.71 | –3.423 | 0.001** | 6.73±2.86 | –3.617 | 0.000** |
CG | 15.60±2.92 | 18.47±4.08 | –3.196 | 0.001** | 2.87±1.88 | ||
Social relations | |||||||
EG | 8.73±2.21 | 10.87±1.99 | –3.455 | 0.001** | 2.13±0.99 | –3.094 | 0.002** |
CG | 8.67±1.58 | 9.60±1.76 | –2.913 | 0.004** | 0.93±0.88 | ||
Environment | |||||||
EG | 23.53±2.64 | 27.93±3.15 | –3.428 | 0.001** | 4.40±1.95 | –3.524 | 0.000** |
CG | 23.73±2.28 | 25.20±2.65 | –2.842 | 0.004** | 1.47±1.72 | ||
Total score | |||||||
EG | 68.13±8.55 | 86.73±9.52 | –3.411 | 0.001** | 18.60±4.05 | –3.596 | 0.000** |
CG | 66.93±9.27 | 76.87±11.74 | –3.414 | 0.001** | 9.93±5.68 |
Daily living activity-based task | Attention task | Executive function task |
---|---|---|
Climbing stairs | Continuous subtraction | Presenting a virtual situation |
e.g., 20-3-3-3 | e.g., You’re in a taxi but do not have your wallet. | |
Making tea/coffee | Simple addition/subtraction | Explaining the order of wearing clothes |
e.g., 5+4, 9-6 | e.g., Dress, skirt, pants, shirts, tie | |
Folding tops/bottoms | Counting numbers forward/backward in order | Talking about daily routine |
e.g., Counting from 1 to 20 forwards/backwards in order | e.g., Describe your daily routine for today. | |
Buttoning/unbuttoning | Reading words backwards | Making a shopping list |
e.g., Hat, pencil, soap, ballpoint pen | e.g., Make a shopping list for grocery shopping, pharmacy, bookstore. | |
Moving beans | Simple word game of coming up with a word that starts with the last letter of the previous word | Categorization |
e.g., Standing-train-garage | e.g., Types of land animals, types of drinks, colors |
Characteristic | Experimental group (n=15) | Control group (n=15) | p |
---|---|---|---|
Mean age (y) | 65.20±12.17 | 65.27±12.73 | 0.868 |
Sex | 0.715 | ||
Male | 8 (53.3) | 7 (46.7) | |
Female | 7 (46.7) | 8 (53.3) | |
Stroke type | 0.464 | ||
Infarction | 8 (53.3) | 6 (40.0) | |
Hemorrhage | 7 (46.7) | 9 (60.0) | |
Paralyzed side | 0.713 | ||
Right | 6 (40.0) | 7 (46.7) | |
Left | 9 (60.0) | 8 (53.3) | |
Disease duration (mo) | 4.07±0.88 | 4.20±0.77 | 0.691 |
K-MMSE (score) | 24.00±2.00 | 24.00±1.96 | 0.916 |
BRS (phase) | 5.33±0.61 | 5.00±0.65 | 0.161 |
Variable | Intervention with groups |
Difference between groups |
|||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Before (mean±SD) | After (mean±SD) | Z | p | Mean±SD | Z | p | |
Upper extremity training | |||||||
EG | 14.40±1.35 | 15.53±0.74 | –2.724 | 0.006 |
1.13±1.18 | –0.932 | 0.351 |
CG | 14.40±1.45 | 15.20±1.01 | –2.414 | 0.016 |
0.80±1.14 | ||
Grip strength | |||||||
EG | 5.33±0.48 | 5.87±0.35 | –2.530 | 0.011 |
0.67±0.48 | –2.159 | 0.031 |
CG | 5.47±0.51 | 5.73±0.45 | –2.000 | 0.046 |
0.27±0.45 | ||
Finger manipulation | |||||||
EG | 4.60±0.91 | 6.20±1.08 | –3.520 | 0.000 |
1.60±0.50 | –2.361 | 0.018 |
CG | 4.60±0.82 | 5.53±0.99 | –2.889 | 0.004 |
0.93±0.79 | ||
Total score | |||||||
EG | 24.53±1.99 | 27.73±1.58 | –3.438 | 0.001 |
3.20±1.52 | –2.430 | 0.015 |
CG | 24.47±2.06 | 26.40±1.95 | –3.088 | 0.002 |
1.93±1.79 |
Variable | Intervention with groups |
Difference between groups |
|||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Before (mean±SD) | After (mean±SD) | Z | p | Mean±SD | Z | p | |
DST-Forward | |||||||
EG | 5.27±0.88 | 6.93±0.88 | –3.542 | 0.000 |
1.67±0.48 | –3.181 | 0.001 |
CG | 5.20±1.08 | 6.07±1.10 | –3.127 | 0.002 |
0.87±0.64 | ||
DST-Backward | |||||||
EG | 2.60±0.73 | 3.93±0.45 | –3.397 | 0.001 |
1.33±0.61 | –3.500 | 0.000 |
CG | 3.00±0.75 | 3.40±0.73 | –2.449 | 0.0141 |
0.40±0.50 | ||
EFPT-K | |||||||
EG | 12.70±2.51 | 9.96±1.30 | –3.413 | 0.001 |
–2.74±1.29 | –4.720 | 0.000 |
CG | 12.70±2.63 | 11.94±2.58 | –3.474 | 0.001 |
–0.77±0.19 | ||
K-TMT-e B | |||||||
EG | 89.13±10.85 | 67.00±12.16 | –3.411 | 0.001 |
–22.13±4.86 | –3.199 | 0.001 |
CG | 89.60±12.33 | 77.00±13.26 | –3.412 | 0.001 |
–12.60±7.83 |
Variable | Intervention with groups |
Difference between groups |
|||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Before (mean±SD) | After (mean±SD) | Z | p | Mean±SD | Z | p | |
Physical health | |||||||
EG | 19.47±3.50 | 26.00±2.59 | –3.391 | 0.001 |
6.53±2.61 | –3.158 | 0.002 |
CG | 19.93±4.14 | 23.60±4.18 | –3.309 | 0.001 |
3.67±2.09 | ||
Psychology | |||||||
EG | 15.60±2.44 | 22.33±3.71 | –3.423 | 0.001 |
6.73±2.86 | –3.617 | 0.000 |
CG | 15.60±2.92 | 18.47±4.08 | –3.196 | 0.001 |
2.87±1.88 | ||
Social relations | |||||||
EG | 8.73±2.21 | 10.87±1.99 | –3.455 | 0.001 |
2.13±0.99 | –3.094 | 0.002 |
CG | 8.67±1.58 | 9.60±1.76 | –2.913 | 0.004 |
0.93±0.88 | ||
Environment | |||||||
EG | 23.53±2.64 | 27.93±3.15 | –3.428 | 0.001 |
4.40±1.95 | –3.524 | 0.000 |
CG | 23.73±2.28 | 25.20±2.65 | –2.842 | 0.004 |
1.47±1.72 | ||
Total score | |||||||
EG | 68.13±8.55 | 86.73±9.52 | –3.411 | 0.001 |
18.60±4.05 | –3.596 | 0.000 |
CG | 66.93±9.27 | 76.87±11.74 | –3.414 | 0.001 |
9.93±5.68 |
Perform attention tasks while performing daily living activity, or perform executive function task while performing daily living activity.
Data are presented as mean±standard deviation or K-MMSE, Korean version of the Mini-Mental State Examination; BRS, Brunnstrom Recovery Stage.
SD, standard deviation; EG, experimental group; CG, control group.
DST, Digit Span Test; EFPT-K, Executive Function Performance Test Korean version; K-TMT-e B, Korean version of the Trail Making Test for the Elderly B; SD, standard deviation; EG, experimental group; CG, control group.
WHOQOL-BREF, WHO Quality of Life-BREF; SD, standard deviation; EG, experimental group; CG, control group.