1Department of Public Health Dentistry, Rishiraj College of Dental Sciences, Bhopal, India
2Department of Oral Medicine and Radiology, Rishiraj College of Dental Sciences, Bhopal, India
3Department of Pediatrics, Gandhi Medical College and Hamidia Hospital, Bhopal, India
4Department of Dentistry, Regional Training Center for Oral Health Promotion, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Bhopal, India
5Department of Pediatric Surgery, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Bhopal, India
© 2023 Korea Disease Control and Prevention Agency.
This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Ethics Approval
Not applicable.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.
Funding
None.
Availability of Data
The datasets are not publicly available but are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
Authors’ Contributions
Conceptualization: AG, KS, AP; Data curation: AG, AA; Formal analysis: AG, AP; Investigation: AG, KS, AA; Methodology: AG, KS, AA, AP, RC; Project administration: AG, KS; Software: AG, AP; Supervision: AG, AA; Validation: AG, AP; Visualization: AG, RC; Writing–original draft: AG; Writing–review & editing: authors. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
No. | Study | Year of publication | Study location | Study design | Sample size (n) | Sex | Mean age (range, y) | Study duration | Medical history | Admission in the ICU | Risk of bias |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Nuno-Gonzalez et al. [5] | 2021 | Spain | Cross-sectional | 666 | - | 55.7 (40–70) | April 10–25, 2020 | - | History of hospitalization | Low |
2 | Al-Zaidi and Badr [12] | 2020 | Iraq | Cross-sectional | 65 | M, 41.6%; F, 58.4% | 41.2 (11–80) | April 5, 2020–May 17, 2020 | - | - | Moderate |
3 | Biadsee et al. [13] | 2020 | Israel | Cross-sectional | 140 | M, 58; F, 70 | 36.5 (18–73) | March 25, 2020–April 15, 2020 | - | - | Moderate |
4 | Bodnia and Katzenstein [14] | 2020 | Copenhagen, Denmark | Cross-sectional | 51 | F, 22; M, 28 | 45 (16–62) | March 2020 | - | - | Moderate |
5 | Chen et al. [15] | 2020 | China | Cross-sectional | 31 | M, 15; F, 16 | 60.6 (18–86) | February 28, 2020–March 4, 2020 | - | - | Moderate |
6 | Dell’Era et al. [16] | 2020 | Italy | Cross-sectional | 355 | M, 54% | 45 (51–60) | March 10–30, 2020 | Cardiovascular disease, allergic (sinusitis) | - | Low |
7 | Kumar et al. [17] | 2021 | India | Cross-sectional | 141 | M, 58.9%; F, 41.1% | 15.2 (10–19) | May–August 2020 | - | - | Low |
8 | Lechien et al. [18] | 2020 | Europe (multi center) | Cross-sectional | 417 | F, 263; M, 154 | 36.9 (19–77) | - | Allergic rhinitis, asthma, hypertension, hypothyroidism | Hospitalization of severe cases | Low |
9 | Paderno et al. [19] | 2020 | Italy | Cross-sectional | 508 | M, 56%; F, 44% (55±15 y)a) | 55 (40–70) | March 27–April 1, 2020 | - | Hospitalization of severe cases | Low |
10 | Boscolo-Rizzo et al. [20] | 2020 | Italy | Cross-sectional | 202 | F, 55.1%; M, 44.9% | 56 (20–89) | March 19–22, 2020 | - | - | Low |
11 | Yan et al. [21] | 2020 | California, USA | Cross-sectional | 59 and 203 (COVID-19 +ve and –ve) | M & F, 49.2% (COVID-19 +ve): M, 34%; F, 65% (COVID-19 –ve) | 54 (18–80) | March 3–29, 2020 | Allergic rhinitis, immunocompromised state, hypertension, DM, cardiac disorders, cancer, CLD, history of head trauma, neurological disease | Hospitalization of severe cases | Low |
12 | Sinjari et al. [22] | 2020 | Italy | Cross-sectional | 20 | - | 69.2 (39–81) | May 2020–June 2020 | DM, cardiovascular conditions | - | Low |
13 | Giacomelli et al. [23] | 2020 | Italy | Cross-sectional | 59 | M, 40%; F, 60% | 60 (40–74) | March 19, 2020 | - | - | Moderate |
14 | Mascitti et al. [24] | 2020 | France | Cross-sectional | 59 | M:F, 3:1 | 57.6 (49–69) | March 31, 2020 | - | - | Moderate |
15 | Salehi et al. [25] | 2020 | Iran | Cross-sectional | 53 | M, 43.4%; F, 56.6% | 63.1 (27–90) | March 1, 2020–April 30, 2020 | Cardiovascular diseases (52.83%), DM (37.7%), chronic kidney disease (20.7%) | - | Low |
16 | Askin et al. [26] | 2020 | Turkey | Cross-sectional | 210 | M, 58.6%; F, 41.4% | 57.4 (20–75) | April 2020 | Comorbidities | 29 in ICU, 129 in wards | Moderate |
17 | Katz and Yue [27] | 2021 | USA | Retrospective study | 889 | F, 509; M, 386 | 18–34 | Registry study | - | - | Moderate |
18 | Fantozzi et al. [28] | 2020 | Italy | Retrospective study | 326 | M, 52.3%; F, 47.7% | 57 (48–67) | March 6, 2020–April 30, 2020 | Hypertension (n=29), chronic pulmonary disease (n=11), DM (n=10), cardiovascular disease (n=9), cancer (n=5) | Hospitalized (median, 12.5 d) | High |
19 | Favia et al. [29] | 2021 | Bari, Italy | Cross-sectional | 123 | M:F, 1.3:1 | Median, 72 | October 2020–December 2020 | - | History of hospitalization and ICU | Moderate |
20 | Halepas et al. [30] | 2021 | New York, USA | Cross-sectional | 47 | M, 51.1%; F, 48.9% | 9.0 (1.3–20) | March 15–June 1, 2020 | - | History of hospitalization, ICU | Moderate |
21 | Rekhtman et al. [31] | 2021 | New York, USA | Cross-sectional | 296 | M, 71%; F, 29% | 64 (50–77) | May 11, 2020–June 15, 2020 | CAD, 23%; congestive heart failure, 14%; asthma, 9%; COPD, 14%; DM, 34%; hypertension, 71% | History of hospitalization | Low |
22 | Marouf et al. [32] | 2021 | Qatar | Case control | Case, 40; control, 528 | Case: M, 50%; F, 50% | Case, 53.6; control, 41.5 | February–July 2020 | DM: case, 42.5%; control, 27.8% | Hospitalization and ICU admission | Low |
Control: M, 54.9%; F, 45.1% | |||||||||||
23 | Subramaniam et al. [33] | 2021 | India | Cross-sectional | 713 | M:F, 6:3 | 69 (60–81) | May 2020–June 2020 | DM, hypertension | - | Moderate |
24 | Abubakr et al. [34] | 2021 | Egypt | Cross-sectional | 573 | F, 408; M, 165 | 36.19 (30–45) | May 1, 2020–July 1, 2020 | - | - | Low |
25 | Song et al. [35] | 2021 | China | Retrospective | 1172 | - | - | December 2019 | - | History of hospitalization | Low |
26 | Bardellini et al. [36] | 2021 | Italy | Retrospective | 27 | M:F, 19:8 | 4.2 y (3 mo–14 y) | March–April 2020 | - | - | High |
27 | Gherlone et al. [37] | 2021 | Italy | Cross-sectional | 122 | M, 75.4%; F, 24.6% | 62.5 (53.9–74.1) | July 23, 2020–September 7, 2020 | CAD, DM, chronic kidney disease, active neoplasia, COPD | History of hospitalization and ICU and ventilation | High |
28 | El Kady et al. [38] | 2021 | Egypt | Cross-sectional | 58 | M, 53.4%; F, 46.6% | 18–46 | May 15, 2020–June 10, 2020 | - | History of hospitalization | High |
29 | Fidan et al. [39] | 2021 | Turkey | Cross-sectional | 74 | M, 66.2%; F, 33.8% | 51.6 (28–68) | April–October 2020 | - | Hospitalized | High |
30 | Natto et al. [40] | 2021 | Saudi Arabia | Cross-sectional | 109 | M, 67%; F, 33% | 39.3 (18–56) | July–October 2020 | DM (10.1%), hypertension (7.3%), asthma and arthritis (1.7%) | - | Moderate |
31 | Elamrousy et al. [41] | 2021 | Egypt | Cross-sectional | 124 | M, 74.2%; F, 25.8% | 50.32±12.47a) | September 2, 2020–June 10, 2021 | DM (n=52), hypertension (n=16), cardiac disease (n=8), renal disease (n=4), liver disease (n=4) | Hospitalized | Moderate |
32 | Bulut et al. [42] | 2021 | Turkey | Cross-sectional | 200 | M, 75; F, 125 | 38 (20–70) | September 2020–March 2021 | - | Hospitalized (11.5%) | Low |
33 | Naser et al. [43] | 2021 | Iraq | Cross-sectional | 338 | M, 59%; F, 41% | 45 | August 2020–March 2021 | Respiratory diseases, DM, hypertension, heart disease, urogenital diseases | Hospitalized | Moderate |
34 | Muthyam et al. [44] | 2022 | India | Cross-sectional | 100 | M, 51%; F, 49% | More than 35 y, 54%; less than 35 y, 46% | - | Immunocompromised state, multidrug therapy | Hospitalization | Low |
35 | Ganesan et al. [45] | 2022 | India | Cross-sectional | 500 | M, 73.4%; F, 26.6% | 53.46±17.50a) | - | - | - | Low |
36 | El Tantawi et al. [46] | 2022 | Multicountry study (Saudi Arabia) | Cross-sectional | 434 | M, 41.5%; F, 58.5% | 18–23 | August 2020–January 2021 | Cancer, COPD | - | Moderate |
37 | Soares et al. [47] | 2022 | Brazil | Retrospective | 14 | M, 71.5%; F, 38.5% | 58 (20–65) | - | - | - | Low |
38 | Tuter et al. [48] | 2022 | Turkey | Cross-sectional | 204 | M, 37.3%; F, 62.7% | 53.3 (18–70) | February–March 2021 | DM, hypertension, immunosuppression | Hospitalization, ICU | Low |
39 | Schwab et al. [49] | 2022 | Brazil | Cross-sectional | 154 | M, 59.7%; F, 40.3% | 54.60 (20–88) | January 13, 2021–May 28, 2021 | - | Hospitalization, ICU, ventilation | Moderate |
40 | Chawla et al. [50] | 2022 | India | Cross-sectional | 217 | M, 70%; F, 30% | 56 (18–60) | September–December 2020 | DM, hypertension, CAD, bronchial asthma | - | High |
41 | Binmadi et al. [51] | 2022 | Saudi Arabia | Cross-sectional | 195 | M, 25%; F, 75% | 26 (18–34) | March 2020–March 2022 | Immunosuppression, hormonal modulation | Hospitalization, ICU, ventilation | Moderate |
42 | Eduardo et al. [52] | 2022 | Brazil | Retrospective | 519 | M, 68.2%; F, 31.8% | 51–80 | May 2020–February 2021 | - | ICU | Moderate |
43 | Villarroel-Dorrego et al. [53] | 2022 | Spain | Cross-sectional | 55 | M, 54.5%; F, 45.5% | 51 (1–89) | - | - | - | Moderate |
44 | Manifar et al. [54] | 2022 | Iran | Cross-sectional | 140 | M, 44.2%; F, 55.8% | 53.78 (15–92) | September 1, 2020–October 17, 2020 | - | Hospitalization | Moderate |
45 | Bhuyan et al. [55] | 2022 | India | Cross-sectional | 169 (1st wave), 211 (2nd wave) | 1st wave: M, 35.5%; F, 64.5% | 63±17 and 57±18 (1st and 2nd wave)a) | - | Comorbidities | Hospitalization, ventilator | Moderate |
2nd wave: M, 45.5%; F, 55.5% | |||||||||||
46 | Mohammad et al. [84] | 2023 | Iraq | Cross-sectional | 200 | M, 81; F, 119 | 36.69 (16–78) | September–December 2021 | - | - | Moderate |
47 | Al-Magsoosi et al. [85] | 2023 | Iraq | Cross-sectional | 574 | M, 196; F, 378 | 18–78 | October 2021–April 2022 | - | - | Low |
48 | Cazzolla et al. [86] | 2023 | Italy | Cross-sectional | 1,155 | M, 57%; F, 43% | M, 59±13; F, 56± 16a) | March 15, 2020–April 15, 2021 | - | - | Moderate |
49 | Sinadinos and Shelswell [6] | 2020 | United Kingdom | Case series | 3 | M:F, 2:1 | 56 (45–61) | DM, hypertension (case 2); obesity (case 3) | - | Low | |
50 | Dima et al. [8] | 2020 | Romania | Case series | 3 | M:F, 2:1 | Newborns | May 2020 | Diaper erythema | Neonatology ward | Low |
51 | Brandao et al. [56] | 2021 | Brazil | Case series | 8 | M, 5; F, 3 | 53 (28–83) | - | Hypertension, COPD (case 1); DM, obesity, renal failure, bariatric surgery, fibromyalgia (case 2); obesity, Parkinson disease, hypertension, COPD (case 3); DM, hypertension (case 4) | Hospitalization | Low |
52 | Cruz Tapia et al. [57] | 2020 | Latin America | Case series | 4 | F:M, 3:1 | 47.2 (41–54) | - | - | Case 2, hospitalized | Low |
53 | Vaira et al. [58] | 2020 | Italy | Case series | 72 | M, 27; F, 45 | 49.2 (18–67) | March 31, 2020–April 6, 2020 | History of head trauma, allergic rhinitis, chronic rhino sinusitis, psychiatric or neurological disorders | - | Low |
54 | Martin Carreras-Presas et al. [59] | 2021 | Spain | Case series | 3 | M:F, 2:1 | 55 (56–65) | Last week of March–First week of April 2020 | DM, hypertension (case 2); obesity, hypertension (case 3) | Case 3, hospitalization | Low |
55 | Rodriguez et al. [60] | 2022 | Spain | Case series | 3 | F:M, 2:1 | 68 (53–78) | - | - | Case 1, home quarantine; cases 2 & 3, hospitalization | Low |
56 | Corchuelo and Ulloa [61] | 2020 | Colombia | Case report | 1 | F | 40 | - | - | - | Low |
57 | Amorim Dos Santos et al. [9] | 2020 | Brazil | Case report | 1 | M | 67 | March 31, 2020 | CAD, autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease, and kidney transplant, immunosuppression, venous thromboembolism | Hospitalization in ICU | Low |
58 | Eghbali Zarch and Hosseinzadeh [62] | 2021 | Iran | Case report | 1 | F | 56 | October 2020 | - | - | Low |
59 | Hjelmesaeth and Skaare [63] | 2020 | Norway | Case report | 1 | F | 60 | - | - | - | Low |
60 | Cebeci Kahraman and Caskurlu [64] | 2020 | Turkey | Case report | 1 | M | 51 | March 18, 2020 | - | - | Low |
61 | Smith et al. [65] | 2020 | USA | Case report | 1 | M | 21 | March 19, 2020 | - | - | Low |
62 | Maniaci et al. [66] | 2020 | Italy | Case report | 1 | M | 15 | - | - | - | Low |
63 | Melley et al. [67] | 2020 | Pennsylvania, USA | Case report | 1 | F | 59 | May 2020 | - | - | Low |
64 | Riad et al. [68] | 2022 | Egypt | Case report | 1 | F | 47 | - | Cardiovascular disease, DM | - | Low |
65 | Putra et al. [69] | 2020 | Indonesia | Case report | 1 | M | 29 | - | Cardiovascular diseases | - | Low |
66 | Dalipi et al. [70] | 2021 | Europe | Case report | 1 | M | 17 | - | - | - | Low |
67 | Eita [71] | 2021 | Egypt | Case report | 1 | F | 31 | - | Irritable bowel syndrome, atopy | - | Low |
68 | Cirillo and Colella [72] | 2021 | Italy | Case report | 1 | F | 36 | March 2020 | - | - | Low |
69 | Nejabi et al. [73] | 2021 | Afghanistan | Case report | 1 | M | 62 | - | - | - | Low |
70 | Klein et al. [74] | 2021 | Israel | Case report | 1 | F (pregnant) | 40 | - | - | - | Low |
71 | Ramires et al. [75] | 2021 | Brazil | Case report | 1 | F | 50 | - | Obesity, hypertension, type 2 DM | Hospitalization, ventilation | Low |
72 | Hockova et al. [76] | 2021 | Czech Republic | Case series | 3 | M:F, 3:0 | 62 | Arterial hypertension, hypercholesterolemia, GERD (case 1); arterial hypertension, history of MI, septic shock (case 2) | ICU | Low | |
73 | Teixeira et al. [77] | 2021 | Brazil | Case series | 4 | M:F, 1:3 | 68.75 (57–84) | - | Hypertension, hypothyroidism, rectal tumor (case 2); hypertension, hypothyroidism (case 3); bipolar disorder (case 4) | - | Low |
74 | Emelyanova et al. [78] | 2021 | Ukraine | Case report | 1 | F | 38 | - | - | - | Low |
75 | Fathi et al. [79] | 2021 | Iran | Case report | 1 | F | 22 | April 2020 | - | Hospitalization (2nd day) | Low |
76 | Shenoy et al. [80] | 2022 | India | Case report | 1 | F | 55 | - | - | - | Low |
77 | Palaia et al. [81] | 2022 | Italy | Case report | 1 | F | 30 | - | - | - | Low |
78 | Rafalowicz et al. [82] | 2022 | Poland | Case series | 6 | M, 4; F, 2 | 58.8 (43–72) | January–June 2021 | Hypertension, insulin resistance (case 2) | No | Low |
79 | Jogdand et al. [83] | 2023 | India | Case series | 2 | M, 1; F, 1 | 50 and 60 | June 2020 | Diabetes, hypertension (case 1) | No | Low |
No. | Study | Year of publication | Presenting symptoms given by the patient | Site | Oral signs and symptoms | Occurrence/duration of oral manifestation | Systemic manifestation |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Nuno-Gonzalez et al. [5] | 2021 | Oral mucosal changes (11.7%), transient anterior U-shaped lingual papillitis (11.5%), tongue swelling (6.6%), aphthous stomatitis (6.9%), burning sensation in the mouth (5.3%), mucositis (3.9%), glossitis with patchy depapillation (3.9%), white tongue (1.6%), and enanthema (0.5%), taste disturbances | Tongue, oral mucosa | Redness and burning sensation, oral ulceration, red and white lesions, morphological changes of tongue, taste alteration | - | - |
2 | Sinadinos and Shelswell [6] | 2020 | Pain in palate (case 1); pain and ulcerations in palate (case 2), pain in tongue, blisters of the labial mucosa; desquamative gingivitis (case 3) | Palate, tongue, gums, lips | Oral ulceration, vesiculobullous lesions, redness and burning sensation, gingival and periodontal changes | - | Sore throat (case 1), pneumonia (case 3) |
3 | Dima et al. [8] | 2020 | Oral candidiasis | Oral mucosa | Red and white lesions/fungal | - | Epistaxis and diaper erythema (all 3 cases); palpebral edema (newborn 2) |
4 | Amorim Dos Santos et al. [9] | 2020 | Hypogeusia, white plaque, multiple pinpoint yellowish ulcers in the tongue, nodule in lower lip (1 cm) | Tongue, lower lip | Vesiculobullous lesions, red and white lesions, taste alteration | Mean duration, 14 d | Respiratory symptoms and progressive dyspnea on exertion, fever and diarrhea |
5 | Al-Zaidi and Badr [12] | 2020 | Loss of taste (83%) | Tongue | Taste alteration | 1 wk before systemic symptoms | Fever (63.08%), cough (60.00%), dyspnea (47.69%), sore throat, diarrhea (32.31%), chest pain (30.77%) |
6 | Biadsee et al. [13] | 2020 | Taste alteration (n=67), dry mouth (n=72), plaque-like changes in the tongue (n=9), swelling in the oral cavity (n=10) | Tongue, oral mucosa | Red and white lesions, taste alteration, xerostomia | Along with systemic symptoms | Cough and runny nose (p=0.018), olfactory dysfunction |
7 | Bodnia and Katzenstein [14] | 2020 | Total loss of taste (70%) | Tongue | Taste alteration | 1–3 wk (78%), 3–6 wk (22%) | Fatigue, headache, fever, dry cough, disturbance of the sense of smell |
8 | Chen et al. [15] | 2020 | Amblygeustia (47.2%), dry mouth (11.1%) | Tongue, oral mucosa | Taste alteration, xerostomia | Along with systemic symptoms | Submandibular lymph node enlargement (n=1), cough (n=21), fever (n=20), diarrhea (n=4), chest tightness (n=13) |
9 | Dell’Era et al. [16] | 2020 | Taste disorders (65.5%) | Tongue | Taste alteration | Mean duration, 10 d | Fever (72.1%), cough (47.9%), fatigue (40.3%), dyspnea (21.7%), diarrhea (19.7%) |
10 | Kumar et al. [17] | 2021 | Taste, dysfunction (28.4%) | Tongue | Taste alteration | Duration, 2–15 d | Malaise (14.2%), sore throat (19.9%), cough (20.6%), fever (48.2%), diarrhea (5.7%), nasal discharge (3.5%), headache (5.7%) |
11 | Lechien et al. [18] | 2020 | Gustatory dysfunction (88.8%) | Tongue | Taste alteration | Mean duration, 9.2±6.2 d | Olfactory dysfunction (85.6%) |
12 | Paderno et al. [19] | 2020 | Gustatory dysfunction (group A, 51.9%; group B, 78.9%); partial, 36.8%; total, 60.1%; unable to assess, 3.1% | Tongue | Taste alteration | First symptom in 11.9% (group A) and 10.2% (group B); mean duration, 9.2±5.4 | Olfactory dysfunction, fever, cough, headache, dyspnea, asthenia, diarrhea, nausea, nasal congestion, pharyngodynia |
13 | Boscolo-Rizzo et al. [20] | 2020 | Loss of taste (n=113) | Tongue | Taste alteration | Mean duration, 9.5 d | Dry cough, fever, headache, sore throat, chest pain, nausea, abdominal pain |
14 | Yan et al. [21] | 2020 | Gustatory impairment (71%) (p<0.001) | Tongue | Taste alteration | - | Fatigue (81%), fever (70%), anosmia (68%), myalgia or arthralgia (63%), diarrhea (48%), nausea (27%) |
15 | Sinjari et al. [22] | 2020 | Impaired taste (25%), burning sensation (15%), difficulty in swallowing (20%), dry mouth (30%) (p=0.02) | Oral mucosa, tongue | Redness and burning sensation, taste alteration, xerostomia | - | - |
16 | Giacomelli et al. [23] | 2020 | Dysgeusia (8.5%), ageusia (1.7%) | Tongue | Taste alteration | Before hospitalization (91%) | Fever (72.8%), cough (37.3%), dyspnea (25.4%), sore throat (1.7%), arthralgia (5.1%), headache (3.4%), asthenia (1.7%), abdominal symptoms (8.5%) |
17 | Mascitti et al. [24] | 2020 | Oral lichenoid reaction (32.5%), oral enanthema (27.5%), macroglossia (25.0%), cheilitis (12.5%), ageusia (20.5%), extensive ulcerations of the tongue (2.5%) | Lips, tongue, oral mucosa | Oral ulceration, vesiculobullous lesions. taste alteration | - | Macular exanthema (80%), face edema (32%), livedo (13%), urticarial rash (8%), purpura (5%), oral lichenoid lesions (33%), conjunctivitis (18%) |
18 | Salehi et al. [25] | 2020 | White plaques on the intraoral mucous layer of oral mucosa | Oral mucosa | Red and white lesions | - | - |
19 | Askin et al. [26] | 2020 | Aphthous stomatitis (5.8%), rash and erythema, aphthous lesion on side of tongue | Tongue, oral mucosa | Vesiculobullous lesions, redness and burning sensation | - | Cutaneous findings (36.1%) |
20 | Katz and Yue [27] | 2021 | Recurrent aphthous stomatitis (0.64%) | Oral mucosa | Oral ulceration | - | - |
21 | Fantozzi et al. [28] | 2020 | Dry mouth (45.9%), swallowing difficulties (39.2%), dysgeusia (59.5%) | Tongue, oral mucosa | Redness and burning sensation, oral ulceration, taste alteration, xerostomia | First symptom (xerostomia) (19.6%); dysgeusia (87.9%), duration (xerostomia), 7 d; dysgeusia 6 d | Fever (90.9%), cough (46.8%), dyspnea (34.3%), diarrhea (4.5%), sore throat (3.6%), fatigue (3.6%), myalgia/arthralgia (2.7%), vomiting (2.7%) |
22 | Favia et al. [29] | 2021 | Geographic tongue (n=7), fissured tongue (n=5), ulcerative lesion (n=65), blisters (n=19), hyperplasia of papillae (n=48), angina bullosa (n=11), candidiasis (n=28), ulceronecrotic gingivitis (n=7), petechiae (n=14), oral haemorrhage (n=1), taste disorders (90%) | Tongue, oral mucosa, lips | Red and white lesions, morphological changes of tongue, vesiculobullous lesions, oral ulceration, taste alteration | Together with general symptoms (26.2%); duration, 1 wk (41%); after 1 wk of general symptoms (32.6%) | Fever, anosmia, cough, sore throat, congestion, runny nose, nausea or vomiting, muscle and body aches, dermatologic manifestation, pneumonia, dyspnea, hypoxia (SpO2 <90%) |
23 | Halepas et al. 2021 [30] | 2021 | Red and/or swollen lips (48.9%), strawberry tongue (10.6%) | Lips, tongue | Redness and burning sensation, morphological changes of tongue | - | Fever |
24 | Rekhtman et al. [31] | 2021 | Rashes on lips and tongue (5.7% and 2.9%), ulcers on lips and tongue | Lips and tongue | Redness and burning sensation, oral ulceration | Generalized rashes | |
25 | Marouf et al. [32] | 2021 | Periodontitis (258/568) | Periodontium | Gingival and periodontal changes | - | - |
26 | Subramaniam et al. [33] | 2021 | Ulcers on oral mucosa; burning mouth and mucositis on lower labial mucosa, papillary atrophy; reddish-white spots on the palate; ulcers on lower lip; pallor of lip | Oral mucosa palate, lips, tongue | Oral ulceration, petechiae, redness and burning sensation, morphological changes of tongue | - | Fever, cough, dyspnea, runny nose, chest tightness, loss of smell |
27 | Abubakr et al. [34] | 2021 | Dental pain (23%), pain in jaw bones or joint (12.0%), halitosis (10.5%), ulcerations (20.4%), dry mouth (47.6%) | Oral mucosa | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, xerostomia | - | Fever, myalgia, dysphagia, and hyposmia, loss of smell, nasal itching |
28 | Song et al. [35] | 2021 | Loss of taste (20.6%) | Tongue | Taste alteration | First symptom (0.4%), recovery time, 7 d | Nasal obstruction (8.6%), rhinorrhea (10.3%), nasal itching (4.9%), sneezing (11.0%), loss of smell (11.4%) |
29 | Bardellini et al. [36] | 2021 | Oral pseudomembranous candidiasis (7.4%), geographic tongue (3.7%), coated tongue (7.4%), taste alteration (11.1%) | Tongue, oral mucosa | Red and white lesions, morphological changes of tongue, taste alteration | - | Fever, cough, rhinorrhoea, breathing difficulty |
30 | Gherlone et al. [37] | 2021 | Salivary gland ectasia (38%), dry mouth (30%), dysgeusia (17%), white plaque (28%), oral ulcers (12%) | Salivary glands, tongue, oral mucosa | Red and white lesions, oral ulceration, xerostomia, salivary gland disorder | - | - |
31 | El Kady et al. [38] | 2021 | Dry mouth (39.7%), loss of salt sensation (34.5%), loss of sweet sensation (29.3%), altered food taste (25.9%), tongue redness (8.8%), gingival bleeding (7%), salivary glands infection (22.4%), swellings in the salivary gland or cheek (13.8%), pain or swelling below mandible (10.8%), burning mouth sensation (22.4%), ulcers (17.2%) | Tongue, salivary glands, gingiva, oral mucosa | Redness and burning sensation, taste alteration, xerostomia, gingival and periodontal changes, salivary gland disorder | - | - |
32 | Fidan et al. [39] | 2021 | Aphthous-like ulcer (36.5%), erythema (25.7%), lichen planus (16.2%), tongue (31.8%), oral mucosa (27.0%), gingiva (18.9%), palate (5.4%) | Tongue (39.7%), oral mucosa (34.5%), gingiva (18.9%), palate (6.9%) | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, red and white lesions | Oral lesions prior COVID-19 diagnosis | - |
33 | Natto et al. [40] | 2021 | Loss of taste (43.4%), erythema/desquamated gingivitis and coated tongue (7.3%), ulcers/blisters (6.4%), pain and soreness (2.8%), dry mouth (0.9%) | Tongue, gingiva, oral mucosa | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, taste alteration, xerostomia, gingival changes | After systemic symptoms | Cough, fever, sore throat, runny nose, muscle pain, headaches, nausea, diarrhea |
34 | Elamrousy et al. [41] | 2021 | Oral ulcers (92.8%), dry mouth (84%), loss of taste (55%), hemorrhagic ulcers with crust on lips | Lip (42.3%), tongue (38.5%), labial mucosa (34.6%) | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, taste alteration, xerostomia | - | Asthenia (67.7%), breath problems (67.7%), cough (67.7%), fatigue (19.4%), abdominal symptoms (12.9%) |
35 | Bulut et al. [42] | 2021 | Taste loss (53%), halitosis (21%), oropharyngeal wound and pain (18%), pain in the chewing muscles (16%), gum bleeding (17.5%), dry mouth (38%, after recovery 12.0%), aphthous ulcer (14.5%), sensitivity and/or pain in teeth (12%), herpes labialis (8.5%), burning in the tongue (7.5%) | Tongue, gingiva, lips | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, taste alteration, xerostomia | - | Presence of symptoms (87.5%) |
36 | Naser et al. [43] | 2021 | Burning sensation (6%), numbness or tingling of the tongue (2%), white coat of the tongue, gingiva, palate (31.6%, 22.4%, 15.6%), loss of taste (79.5%), aphthous ulcers (24.8%), black discoloration of oral cavity, lips and tongue (4.7%, 6.8%), yellow coating on lips (5.3%) | Tongue, palate, lips, oral mucosa | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, red and white lesions, taste alteration | - | - |
37 | Muthyam et al. [44] | 2022 | Dry mouth (44%) followed by swallowing difficulty, mouth ulcerations, chewing problems, gum bleeding, and burning sensation, altered taste (72%); fissured tongue, halitosis, and loss of taste, 2% | Gums, tongue, oral mucosa | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, morphological changes of tongue, taste alteration, xerostomia | Altered taste lasted more than 1 wk (53%) | Weakness (8%), cough and cold (4%), body pain (2%) |
38 | Ganesan et al. [45] | 2022 | Gustatory disturbance (51.2%); dry mouth (28%); erythema, ulcers and depapillation of tongue (15.5%); A statistically significant correlation between oral manifestations and disease severity (p≤0.001). | Tongue, oral mucosa | Morphological changes of tongue, oral ulceration, taste alteration, xerostomia | - | - |
39 | El Tantawi et al. [46] | 2022 | Dry mouth (11.1% vs. 7.5%, p=0.009) and change in taste (11.5% vs. 2.7%, p<0.001) were greater in COVID-19 person; leukoplakia (4.6%); ulcers & hairy tongue (2.3%); gingival redness and burning sensation (13.1%) | Oral mucosa tongue, gingiva | Morphological changes of tongue, oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, taste alteration, xerostomia, gingival and periodontal changes | - | - |
40 | Soares et al. [47] | 2022 | Ulcerative lesions in the palate (57.1%), tongue (29%), lips or palate (14.3%) | Tongue, lips, palate | Oral ulceration | - | Anosmia, fever, headache |
41 | Tuter et al. [48] | 2022 | Dry mouth (44.2%), oral ulceration (22.4%), oral mucosa (15.2%), tongue (10.8%) | Tongue, oral mucosa | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation | - | - |
42 | Schwab et al. [49] | 2022 | Ageusia (11.0%); opportunistic oral infections such as pseudomembranous candidiasis and herpes simplex (4.5%) | Tongue | Red and white lesions/fungal, taste alteration, oral ulceration | - | Cough (72.7%), dyspnoea (63.0%), fever (53.9%), anosmia (14.3%) |
43 | Chawla et al. [50] | 2022 | Dry mouth (38%) (p=0.03), dysgeusia (32%) (p=0.04), vesiculobullous lesion (13%), oral ulcers (3.7%) | Oral mucosa tongue | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, vesiculobullous lesions, taste alteration, xerostomia | - | Cough (30%), sore throat (20%), shortness of breath (7%), running nose (11%) |
44 | Binmadi et al. [51] | 2022 | Taste disturbance (60%); dry mouth (42%); oral ulcerations (11%); gingivitis/petechiae/candidiasis (6%); necrotizing periodontal disease/vesiculobullous lesions/erythema migrans/geographic tongue (4%) | Gingiva, tongue, oral mucosa | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, vesiculobullous lesions, morphological changes of tongue, red and white lesions, taste alteration, xerostomia | Concurrently (47%), after the general symptoms (43%), before the general symptoms (9%) | Fever (95%), headache (65%), fatigue (65%), cough (63%), myalgia/arthralgia (53%), loss of smell (53%), sore throat (50%), shortness of breath or dyspnea (40%), nausea or vomiting (21%), diarrhea (15%) |
45 | Eduardo et al. [52] | 2022 | Saliva alterations (24.4%), dryness (9.9%), tongue coating (3%), sialorrhea (3.3%), petechiae (10.5%), oral bleeding (7.5%) | Oral mucosa tongue, salivary glands | Red and white lesions, redness and burning sensation, salivary gland disorder, xerostomia | - | - |
46 | Villarroel-Dorrego et al. [53] | 2022 | Hemorrhagic ulcerative lesions (7.3%), erythematous and pseudomembranous forms of candidiasis (12.7%), angular cheilitis (1.5%), total loss of taste (60%), burning mouth (36.4%), dry mouth (27.3%) | Tongue, lips, oral mucosa | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, red and white, lesions, xerostomia | - | - |
47 | Manifar et al. [54] | 2022 | Dry mouth (68.6%) (p<0.001), dysgeusia (51.4%) (p<0.001), hypogeusia (49.3%), halitosis (31.4%), metallic taste (29.3%) | Tongue, oral mucosa | Redness and burning sensation, taste alteration, xerostomia | - | Gastrointestinal symptoms, smell defects, asthma, skin rashes, cough, malaise, myalgia, anorexia, respiratory distress, olfactory dysfunction |
48 | Bhuyan et al. [55] | 2022 | Burning sensation (2.4%), dry mouth (2.4%), loss of taste (31%) (p<0.001), mouth ulcer (2.4%), bleeding gum (2.4%) | Oral mucosa gums, tongue | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, taste alteration, xerostomia, gingival changes | - | - |
49 | Brandao et al. [56] | 2021 | Multiple aphthous-like ulcers covered with mucopurulent membrane in the upper and lower lip mucosa and tongue (cases 1, 2, 4, 5); ulcers on tongue and hard palate (case 3); ulcers on tongue and ageusia (cases 6, 7, 8) | Lips, tongue, palate | Oral ulceration, taste alteration | 6–10 d | Chest tightness, fever, cough (cases 1, 5, 7, 8); cough, fever, dyspnea (cases 2, 6); abdominal distension, fever, mild dyspnea (cases 3, 4) |
50 | Cruz Tapia et al. [57] | 2020 | Bulla on the hard palate (×6 mm) (case 1); diffuse purple macule (×12 mm) and papule-plaque (×8 mm) on the left and right palatal mucosa (case 2); tongue enlargement (case 3); Burning mouth sensation and reddish macules on hard palate (case 4) | Palate, tongue | Redness and burning sensation, vesiculobullous lesions, morphological changes of tongue | Fever, myalgia, dysphagia, hyposmia | |
51 | Vaira et al. [58] | 2020 | Hypogeusia (33 cases); complete ageusia (1 case) | Tongue | Taste alteration | Fever, cough, nasal obstruction, sore throat, hyposmia, anosmia, pneumonia | |
52 | Martin Carreras-Presas et al. [59] | 2021 | Dysgeusia (case 1); multiple ulcers | Tongue, lips | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, vesiculobullous lesions, taste alteration, gingival changes | Along with systemic symptoms | Asthenia, hyposmia, enlargement of lymph nodes in the neck (cases 1, 3); fever, diarrhea (case 2) |
On palate (case 2); pain on tongue, blisters in lip mucosa and | |||||||
Desquamative gingivitis (case 3) | |||||||
53 | Rodriguez et al. [60] | 2022 | Dysgeusia, aphthous‐like lesions, burning sensation, and tongue depapillation (case 1); burning mouth sensation and unilateral commissural fissures (case 2); dry mouth, lesions on the tongue, palate, and commissure (case 3) | Tongue, palate, oral mucosa | Redness and burning sensation, morphological changes of tongue, taste alteration, xerostomia | Before presentation (case 1); after discharge (case 2); with systemic symptoms (case 3) | Fever, malaise, anosmia, diarrhea, pneumonia (cases 1, 3) |
54 | Corchuelo and Ulloa [61] | 2020 | Reddish plaques on the lower lip, dark brown pigmentation and aphthous ulcers in the gums, whitish area in tongue | Lower lips, gums | Oral ulceration, vesiculobullous lesions, red and white lesions | Mean duration, 8–10 d | - |
55 | Eghbali Zarch and Hosseinzadeh [62] | 2021 | Vesicles on lower lip mucosa | Lip | Vesiculobullous lesions | 2 d before systemic symptoms | High fever, fatigue, lack of appetite |
56 | Hjelmesaeth and Skaare [63] | 2020 | Total ageusia | Tongue | Taste alteration | - | - |
57 | Cebeci Kahraman and Caskurlu [64] | 2020 | Erythematous surface (hard palate), few petechiae in the midline and numerous pustular enanthema near the soft palate border | Palate | Red and white lesions, oral ulceration | Mean duration, 10 d | Sore throat; fever, fatigue, severe dry cough, inability to taste or smell |
58 | Smith et al. [65] | 2020 | Loss of taste | Tongue | Taste alteration | Before general symptoms | Frontal headache, loss of smell, headache, loose stools |
59 | Maniaci et al. [66] | 2020 | Transient loss of taste | Tongue | Taste alteration | Mean duration, 12 d | Fever, sore throat, runny nose, presence of erythematous skin lesions on the lower limbs, asthenia |
60 | Melley et al. [67] | 2020 | Loss of taste | Tongue | Taste alteration | 1 wk before systemic presentation | Shortness of breath, fatigue, loss of appetite |
61 | Riad et al. [68] | 2022 | Painful white patches on the dorsal surface of the tongue and palate, mild tongue pain | Tongue, palate | Red and white lesions | 2 wk before diagnosis | Sore throat, generalized myalgia, fatigue with intermittent fever |
62 | Putra et al. [69] | 2020 | Stomatitis aphthous | Oral mucosa | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation | Day 7 | Fever, back pain, myalgia, sore throat, dry cough, rhinorrhea, anosmia |
63 | Dalipi et al. [70] | 2021 | Loss of taste | Tongue, lips | Vesiculobullous lesions, taste alteration | Loss of taste, 2 wk before diagnosis | Fever, cough, headache, muscle pain, loss of smell, dark red, purpuric, irregular maculopapular lesions on abdomen |
Bullous and erosive erythematous lesions of lips and oral mucosa | |||||||
64 | Eita [71] | 2021 | Dysgeusia and greasy tongue coat | Tongue | Morphological changes of tongue, taste alteration | Before systemic symptoms | Sore throat, fever (38 °C), nasal congestion, conjunctivitis, nausea; abdominal pain, diarrhea, fatigue, severe joint pain |
65 | Cirillo and Colella [72] | 2021 | Loss of taste | Tongue | Taste alteration | 1 wk before presentation | Loss of smell, headache, fatigue, muscle pain |
66 | Nejabi et al. [73] | 2021 | Fissured tongue, white scars and painful erosive ulcer on the dorsal surface of the tongue | Tongue | Morphological changes of tongue, oral ulceration | After 1 wk of general symptoms | Fever, cough, taste alterations, olfactory dysfunction, chest tightness |
67 | Klein et al. [74] | 2021 | Loss of taste | Tongue | Taste alteration | From 4th to 6 wk | Fever, dry cough, chest pain, sore throat, diarrhea, nausea, headache, back pain |
68 | Ramires et al. [75] | 2021 | Crusted ulcers on lip vermilion (both upper and lower lips) | Lip | Oral ulceration | 2 wk after the onset of fever | Flu-like syndrome: severe and progressive dyspnea (SpO2=88%) |
69 | Hockova et al. [76] | 2021 | Oral lesions at the dorsal surface of the tongue (case 1); multiple lesions located on the tongue dorsum and labial mucosa (case 2); lesions on upper and lower lip (case 3) | Tongue, lips | Oral ulceration | After the diagnosis (all 3 cases) | Headache, fever, dry cough, dyspnoea |
70 | Teixeira et al. [77] | 2021 | Painful vesiculobullous lip lesions | Lips | Vesiculobullous lesions | After 4 d (case 1); after 10 d (case 2); after 11 d (case 3); after 19 d (case 4) | Headache, myalgia, dyspnea |
71 | Emelyanova et al. [78] | 2021 | Unusual tongue appearance and burning sensation, intermittent bleeding of gums, severe dryness in the oral cavity and persistent distortion of taste | Tongue, gums, oral mucosa | Redness and burning sensation, morphological changes of tongue, xerostomia | 3rd day (dysgeusia) and 5th day (xerostomia) after systemic symptoms | Rhinorrhea, coughing and increased body temperature to 38.5 °C |
72 | Fathi et al. [79] | 2021 | Oral pain, ulcerative lesions on oral mucosa, hemorrhagic crusts on lips | Oral mucosa, lips | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation | 3rd day (oral pain) | Fever, abdominal pain, nausea, occasional vomiting |
73 | Shenoy et al. [80] | 2022 | Ulcer with irregular borders on the dorsum of the tongue surrounded by a scrapable whitish plaque | Tongue | Oral ulceration, red and white lesions | Systemic symptoms, 3 wk prior | Fever, cough, chest tightness |
74 | Palaia et al. [81] | 2022 | Extensive erosions involving lips, ulcers on the hard palate, blisters and ulcers on the dorsal surface of the tongue cheek mucosa | Palate, lips, oral mucosa | Oral ulceration, vesiculobullous lesions, redness and burning sensation | 7 d prior to general symptoms (duration of oral lesions, 14 d) | Bilateral cutaneous lesions were also evident on the hands. Low-grade fever |
75 | Rafalowiczet al. [82] | 2022 | Unilateral aphthous-like lesions on the left side of the hard palate (case 1 & 5); hemorrhagic changes on the palate and cheilitis (case 2); smooth tongue with intensely red-purple mucosa (case 3); angioma-type lesion on the right side of the palate (case 4); mycosis of the tongue, extensive lesions on the palate, cheilitis (case 6) | Hard palate, tongue, lips | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, red and white/fungal, morphological changes of tongue | - | Fever, malaise, taste disorders, anosmia, and pneumonia (case 1); dyspnea, persistent diarrhea, and vomiting (case 2); loss of smell and taste and fever for 9 d (cases 4, 5) |
76 | Jogdand et al. [83] | 2023 | Ulcers with yellowish gray pseudo-membrane on oral mucosa and palate | Oral mucosa, palate | Oral ulceration, red and white lesions | - | - |
77 | Mohammad et al. [84] | 2023 | Dry mouth (50%), gustatory dysfunction (37%), burning mouth sensation (22.5%), oral pain (17%), aphthous lesions, fissural cheilitis and tongue depapillation (9.5%), candidiasis (7.5%), gingival bleeding (2.5%) | Gingiva, oral mucosa, tongue | Oral ulceration, red and white lesions, morphological changes of tongue, taste alteration, xerostomia, gingival changes | - | Fever (83.5%), weakness (80%), myalgia (73%), headache (70%), cough (65%), loss of smell sensation (54%), loss of taste sensation (48.5%), sore throat (38.5%), nasal congestion (26.5%), runny nose (25%), gastrointestinal symptom (24.5%) |
78 | Al-Magsoosi et al. [85] | 2023 | Ageusia (66.8%), dry mouth (59%), gustatory changes (46%), dysphagia (40.5%), burning sensation (20.8%), oral ulceration (14.5%), gingival bleeding (3.3%) | Tongue, oral mucosa, gingiva | Redness and burning sensation, taste alteration, xerostomia | - | - |
79 | Cazzolla et al. [86] | 2023 | Taste dysfunction (208/25%) | Tongue | Taste alteration | 1 wk before general symptoms | Fever, breathing, asthenia, rhinorrhea, headache, abdominal symptoms, sore throat, chest pain, cough |
No. | Study | Year of publication | Study location | Study design | Sample size (n) | Sex | Mean age (range, y) | Study duration | Medical history | Admission in the ICU | Risk of bias |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Nuno-Gonzalez et al. [5] | 2021 | Spain | Cross-sectional | 666 | - | 55.7 (40–70) | April 10–25, 2020 | - | History of hospitalization | Low |
2 | Al-Zaidi and Badr [12] | 2020 | Iraq | Cross-sectional | 65 | M, 41.6%; F, 58.4% | 41.2 (11–80) | April 5, 2020–May 17, 2020 | - | - | Moderate |
3 | Biadsee et al. [13] | 2020 | Israel | Cross-sectional | 140 | M, 58; F, 70 | 36.5 (18–73) | March 25, 2020–April 15, 2020 | - | - | Moderate |
4 | Bodnia and Katzenstein [14] | 2020 | Copenhagen, Denmark | Cross-sectional | 51 | F, 22; M, 28 | 45 (16–62) | March 2020 | - | - | Moderate |
5 | Chen et al. [15] | 2020 | China | Cross-sectional | 31 | M, 15; F, 16 | 60.6 (18–86) | February 28, 2020–March 4, 2020 | - | - | Moderate |
6 | Dell’Era et al. [16] | 2020 | Italy | Cross-sectional | 355 | M, 54% | 45 (51–60) | March 10–30, 2020 | Cardiovascular disease, allergic (sinusitis) | - | Low |
7 | Kumar et al. [17] | 2021 | India | Cross-sectional | 141 | M, 58.9%; F, 41.1% | 15.2 (10–19) | May–August 2020 | - | - | Low |
8 | Lechien et al. [18] | 2020 | Europe (multi center) | Cross-sectional | 417 | F, 263; M, 154 | 36.9 (19–77) | - | Allergic rhinitis, asthma, hypertension, hypothyroidism | Hospitalization of severe cases | Low |
9 | Paderno et al. [19] | 2020 | Italy | Cross-sectional | 508 | M, 56%; F, 44% (55±15 y) |
55 (40–70) | March 27–April 1, 2020 | - | Hospitalization of severe cases | Low |
10 | Boscolo-Rizzo et al. [20] | 2020 | Italy | Cross-sectional | 202 | F, 55.1%; M, 44.9% | 56 (20–89) | March 19–22, 2020 | - | - | Low |
11 | Yan et al. [21] | 2020 | California, USA | Cross-sectional | 59 and 203 (COVID-19 +ve and –ve) | M & F, 49.2% (COVID-19 +ve): M, 34%; F, 65% (COVID-19 –ve) | 54 (18–80) | March 3–29, 2020 | Allergic rhinitis, immunocompromised state, hypertension, DM, cardiac disorders, cancer, CLD, history of head trauma, neurological disease | Hospitalization of severe cases | Low |
12 | Sinjari et al. [22] | 2020 | Italy | Cross-sectional | 20 | - | 69.2 (39–81) | May 2020–June 2020 | DM, cardiovascular conditions | - | Low |
13 | Giacomelli et al. [23] | 2020 | Italy | Cross-sectional | 59 | M, 40%; F, 60% | 60 (40–74) | March 19, 2020 | - | - | Moderate |
14 | Mascitti et al. [24] | 2020 | France | Cross-sectional | 59 | M:F, 3:1 | 57.6 (49–69) | March 31, 2020 | - | - | Moderate |
15 | Salehi et al. [25] | 2020 | Iran | Cross-sectional | 53 | M, 43.4%; F, 56.6% | 63.1 (27–90) | March 1, 2020–April 30, 2020 | Cardiovascular diseases (52.83%), DM (37.7%), chronic kidney disease (20.7%) | - | Low |
16 | Askin et al. [26] | 2020 | Turkey | Cross-sectional | 210 | M, 58.6%; F, 41.4% | 57.4 (20–75) | April 2020 | Comorbidities | 29 in ICU, 129 in wards | Moderate |
17 | Katz and Yue [27] | 2021 | USA | Retrospective study | 889 | F, 509; M, 386 | 18–34 | Registry study | - | - | Moderate |
18 | Fantozzi et al. [28] | 2020 | Italy | Retrospective study | 326 | M, 52.3%; F, 47.7% | 57 (48–67) | March 6, 2020–April 30, 2020 | Hypertension (n=29), chronic pulmonary disease (n=11), DM (n=10), cardiovascular disease (n=9), cancer (n=5) | Hospitalized (median, 12.5 d) | High |
19 | Favia et al. [29] | 2021 | Bari, Italy | Cross-sectional | 123 | M:F, 1.3:1 | Median, 72 | October 2020–December 2020 | - | History of hospitalization and ICU | Moderate |
20 | Halepas et al. [30] | 2021 | New York, USA | Cross-sectional | 47 | M, 51.1%; F, 48.9% | 9.0 (1.3–20) | March 15–June 1, 2020 | - | History of hospitalization, ICU | Moderate |
21 | Rekhtman et al. [31] | 2021 | New York, USA | Cross-sectional | 296 | M, 71%; F, 29% | 64 (50–77) | May 11, 2020–June 15, 2020 | CAD, 23%; congestive heart failure, 14%; asthma, 9%; COPD, 14%; DM, 34%; hypertension, 71% | History of hospitalization | Low |
22 | Marouf et al. [32] | 2021 | Qatar | Case control | Case, 40; control, 528 | Case: M, 50%; F, 50% | Case, 53.6; control, 41.5 | February–July 2020 | DM: case, 42.5%; control, 27.8% | Hospitalization and ICU admission | Low |
Control: M, 54.9%; F, 45.1% | |||||||||||
23 | Subramaniam et al. [33] | 2021 | India | Cross-sectional | 713 | M:F, 6:3 | 69 (60–81) | May 2020–June 2020 | DM, hypertension | - | Moderate |
24 | Abubakr et al. [34] | 2021 | Egypt | Cross-sectional | 573 | F, 408; M, 165 | 36.19 (30–45) | May 1, 2020–July 1, 2020 | - | - | Low |
25 | Song et al. [35] | 2021 | China | Retrospective | 1172 | - | - | December 2019 | - | History of hospitalization | Low |
26 | Bardellini et al. [36] | 2021 | Italy | Retrospective | 27 | M:F, 19:8 | 4.2 y (3 mo–14 y) | March–April 2020 | - | - | High |
27 | Gherlone et al. [37] | 2021 | Italy | Cross-sectional | 122 | M, 75.4%; F, 24.6% | 62.5 (53.9–74.1) | July 23, 2020–September 7, 2020 | CAD, DM, chronic kidney disease, active neoplasia, COPD | History of hospitalization and ICU and ventilation | High |
28 | El Kady et al. [38] | 2021 | Egypt | Cross-sectional | 58 | M, 53.4%; F, 46.6% | 18–46 | May 15, 2020–June 10, 2020 | - | History of hospitalization | High |
29 | Fidan et al. [39] | 2021 | Turkey | Cross-sectional | 74 | M, 66.2%; F, 33.8% | 51.6 (28–68) | April–October 2020 | - | Hospitalized | High |
30 | Natto et al. [40] | 2021 | Saudi Arabia | Cross-sectional | 109 | M, 67%; F, 33% | 39.3 (18–56) | July–October 2020 | DM (10.1%), hypertension (7.3%), asthma and arthritis (1.7%) | - | Moderate |
31 | Elamrousy et al. [41] | 2021 | Egypt | Cross-sectional | 124 | M, 74.2%; F, 25.8% | 50.32±12.47 |
September 2, 2020–June 10, 2021 | DM (n=52), hypertension (n=16), cardiac disease (n=8), renal disease (n=4), liver disease (n=4) | Hospitalized | Moderate |
32 | Bulut et al. [42] | 2021 | Turkey | Cross-sectional | 200 | M, 75; F, 125 | 38 (20–70) | September 2020–March 2021 | - | Hospitalized (11.5%) | Low |
33 | Naser et al. [43] | 2021 | Iraq | Cross-sectional | 338 | M, 59%; F, 41% | 45 | August 2020–March 2021 | Respiratory diseases, DM, hypertension, heart disease, urogenital diseases | Hospitalized | Moderate |
34 | Muthyam et al. [44] | 2022 | India | Cross-sectional | 100 | M, 51%; F, 49% | More than 35 y, 54%; less than 35 y, 46% | - | Immunocompromised state, multidrug therapy | Hospitalization | Low |
35 | Ganesan et al. [45] | 2022 | India | Cross-sectional | 500 | M, 73.4%; F, 26.6% | 53.46±17.50 |
- | - | - | Low |
36 | El Tantawi et al. [46] | 2022 | Multicountry study (Saudi Arabia) | Cross-sectional | 434 | M, 41.5%; F, 58.5% | 18–23 | August 2020–January 2021 | Cancer, COPD | - | Moderate |
37 | Soares et al. [47] | 2022 | Brazil | Retrospective | 14 | M, 71.5%; F, 38.5% | 58 (20–65) | - | - | - | Low |
38 | Tuter et al. [48] | 2022 | Turkey | Cross-sectional | 204 | M, 37.3%; F, 62.7% | 53.3 (18–70) | February–March 2021 | DM, hypertension, immunosuppression | Hospitalization, ICU | Low |
39 | Schwab et al. [49] | 2022 | Brazil | Cross-sectional | 154 | M, 59.7%; F, 40.3% | 54.60 (20–88) | January 13, 2021–May 28, 2021 | - | Hospitalization, ICU, ventilation | Moderate |
40 | Chawla et al. [50] | 2022 | India | Cross-sectional | 217 | M, 70%; F, 30% | 56 (18–60) | September–December 2020 | DM, hypertension, CAD, bronchial asthma | - | High |
41 | Binmadi et al. [51] | 2022 | Saudi Arabia | Cross-sectional | 195 | M, 25%; F, 75% | 26 (18–34) | March 2020–March 2022 | Immunosuppression, hormonal modulation | Hospitalization, ICU, ventilation | Moderate |
42 | Eduardo et al. [52] | 2022 | Brazil | Retrospective | 519 | M, 68.2%; F, 31.8% | 51–80 | May 2020–February 2021 | - | ICU | Moderate |
43 | Villarroel-Dorrego et al. [53] | 2022 | Spain | Cross-sectional | 55 | M, 54.5%; F, 45.5% | 51 (1–89) | - | - | - | Moderate |
44 | Manifar et al. [54] | 2022 | Iran | Cross-sectional | 140 | M, 44.2%; F, 55.8% | 53.78 (15–92) | September 1, 2020–October 17, 2020 | - | Hospitalization | Moderate |
45 | Bhuyan et al. [55] | 2022 | India | Cross-sectional | 169 (1st wave), 211 (2nd wave) | 1st wave: M, 35.5%; F, 64.5% | 63±17 and 57±18 (1st and 2nd wave) |
- | Comorbidities | Hospitalization, ventilator | Moderate |
2nd wave: M, 45.5%; F, 55.5% | |||||||||||
46 | Mohammad et al. [84] | 2023 | Iraq | Cross-sectional | 200 | M, 81; F, 119 | 36.69 (16–78) | September–December 2021 | - | - | Moderate |
47 | Al-Magsoosi et al. [85] | 2023 | Iraq | Cross-sectional | 574 | M, 196; F, 378 | 18–78 | October 2021–April 2022 | - | - | Low |
48 | Cazzolla et al. [86] | 2023 | Italy | Cross-sectional | 1,155 | M, 57%; F, 43% | M, 59±13; F, 56± 16 |
March 15, 2020–April 15, 2021 | - | - | Moderate |
49 | Sinadinos and Shelswell [6] | 2020 | United Kingdom | Case series | 3 | M:F, 2:1 | 56 (45–61) | DM, hypertension (case 2); obesity (case 3) | - | Low | |
50 | Dima et al. [8] | 2020 | Romania | Case series | 3 | M:F, 2:1 | Newborns | May 2020 | Diaper erythema | Neonatology ward | Low |
51 | Brandao et al. [56] | 2021 | Brazil | Case series | 8 | M, 5; F, 3 | 53 (28–83) | - | Hypertension, COPD (case 1); DM, obesity, renal failure, bariatric surgery, fibromyalgia (case 2); obesity, Parkinson disease, hypertension, COPD (case 3); DM, hypertension (case 4) | Hospitalization | Low |
52 | Cruz Tapia et al. [57] | 2020 | Latin America | Case series | 4 | F:M, 3:1 | 47.2 (41–54) | - | - | Case 2, hospitalized | Low |
53 | Vaira et al. [58] | 2020 | Italy | Case series | 72 | M, 27; F, 45 | 49.2 (18–67) | March 31, 2020–April 6, 2020 | History of head trauma, allergic rhinitis, chronic rhino sinusitis, psychiatric or neurological disorders | - | Low |
54 | Martin Carreras-Presas et al. [59] | 2021 | Spain | Case series | 3 | M:F, 2:1 | 55 (56–65) | Last week of March–First week of April 2020 | DM, hypertension (case 2); obesity, hypertension (case 3) | Case 3, hospitalization | Low |
55 | Rodriguez et al. [60] | 2022 | Spain | Case series | 3 | F:M, 2:1 | 68 (53–78) | - | - | Case 1, home quarantine; cases 2 & 3, hospitalization | Low |
56 | Corchuelo and Ulloa [61] | 2020 | Colombia | Case report | 1 | F | 40 | - | - | - | Low |
57 | Amorim Dos Santos et al. [9] | 2020 | Brazil | Case report | 1 | M | 67 | March 31, 2020 | CAD, autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease, and kidney transplant, immunosuppression, venous thromboembolism | Hospitalization in ICU | Low |
58 | Eghbali Zarch and Hosseinzadeh [62] | 2021 | Iran | Case report | 1 | F | 56 | October 2020 | - | - | Low |
59 | Hjelmesaeth and Skaare [63] | 2020 | Norway | Case report | 1 | F | 60 | - | - | - | Low |
60 | Cebeci Kahraman and Caskurlu [64] | 2020 | Turkey | Case report | 1 | M | 51 | March 18, 2020 | - | - | Low |
61 | Smith et al. [65] | 2020 | USA | Case report | 1 | M | 21 | March 19, 2020 | - | - | Low |
62 | Maniaci et al. [66] | 2020 | Italy | Case report | 1 | M | 15 | - | - | - | Low |
63 | Melley et al. [67] | 2020 | Pennsylvania, USA | Case report | 1 | F | 59 | May 2020 | - | - | Low |
64 | Riad et al. [68] | 2022 | Egypt | Case report | 1 | F | 47 | - | Cardiovascular disease, DM | - | Low |
65 | Putra et al. [69] | 2020 | Indonesia | Case report | 1 | M | 29 | - | Cardiovascular diseases | - | Low |
66 | Dalipi et al. [70] | 2021 | Europe | Case report | 1 | M | 17 | - | - | - | Low |
67 | Eita [71] | 2021 | Egypt | Case report | 1 | F | 31 | - | Irritable bowel syndrome, atopy | - | Low |
68 | Cirillo and Colella [72] | 2021 | Italy | Case report | 1 | F | 36 | March 2020 | - | - | Low |
69 | Nejabi et al. [73] | 2021 | Afghanistan | Case report | 1 | M | 62 | - | - | - | Low |
70 | Klein et al. [74] | 2021 | Israel | Case report | 1 | F (pregnant) | 40 | - | - | - | Low |
71 | Ramires et al. [75] | 2021 | Brazil | Case report | 1 | F | 50 | - | Obesity, hypertension, type 2 DM | Hospitalization, ventilation | Low |
72 | Hockova et al. [76] | 2021 | Czech Republic | Case series | 3 | M:F, 3:0 | 62 | Arterial hypertension, hypercholesterolemia, GERD (case 1); arterial hypertension, history of MI, septic shock (case 2) | ICU | Low | |
73 | Teixeira et al. [77] | 2021 | Brazil | Case series | 4 | M:F, 1:3 | 68.75 (57–84) | - | Hypertension, hypothyroidism, rectal tumor (case 2); hypertension, hypothyroidism (case 3); bipolar disorder (case 4) | - | Low |
74 | Emelyanova et al. [78] | 2021 | Ukraine | Case report | 1 | F | 38 | - | - | - | Low |
75 | Fathi et al. [79] | 2021 | Iran | Case report | 1 | F | 22 | April 2020 | - | Hospitalization (2nd day) | Low |
76 | Shenoy et al. [80] | 2022 | India | Case report | 1 | F | 55 | - | - | - | Low |
77 | Palaia et al. [81] | 2022 | Italy | Case report | 1 | F | 30 | - | - | - | Low |
78 | Rafalowicz et al. [82] | 2022 | Poland | Case series | 6 | M, 4; F, 2 | 58.8 (43–72) | January–June 2021 | Hypertension, insulin resistance (case 2) | No | Low |
79 | Jogdand et al. [83] | 2023 | India | Case series | 2 | M, 1; F, 1 | 50 and 60 | June 2020 | Diabetes, hypertension (case 1) | No | Low |
No. | Study | Year of publication | Presenting symptoms given by the patient | Site | Oral signs and symptoms | Occurrence/duration of oral manifestation | Systemic manifestation |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Nuno-Gonzalez et al. [5] | 2021 | Oral mucosal changes (11.7%), transient anterior U-shaped lingual papillitis (11.5%), tongue swelling (6.6%), aphthous stomatitis (6.9%), burning sensation in the mouth (5.3%), mucositis (3.9%), glossitis with patchy depapillation (3.9%), white tongue (1.6%), and enanthema (0.5%), taste disturbances | Tongue, oral mucosa | Redness and burning sensation, oral ulceration, red and white lesions, morphological changes of tongue, taste alteration | - | - |
2 | Sinadinos and Shelswell [6] | 2020 | Pain in palate (case 1); pain and ulcerations in palate (case 2), pain in tongue, blisters of the labial mucosa; desquamative gingivitis (case 3) | Palate, tongue, gums, lips | Oral ulceration, vesiculobullous lesions, redness and burning sensation, gingival and periodontal changes | - | Sore throat (case 1), pneumonia (case 3) |
3 | Dima et al. [8] | 2020 | Oral candidiasis | Oral mucosa | Red and white lesions/fungal | - | Epistaxis and diaper erythema (all 3 cases); palpebral edema (newborn 2) |
4 | Amorim Dos Santos et al. [9] | 2020 | Hypogeusia, white plaque, multiple pinpoint yellowish ulcers in the tongue, nodule in lower lip (1 cm) | Tongue, lower lip | Vesiculobullous lesions, red and white lesions, taste alteration | Mean duration, 14 d | Respiratory symptoms and progressive dyspnea on exertion, fever and diarrhea |
5 | Al-Zaidi and Badr [12] | 2020 | Loss of taste (83%) | Tongue | Taste alteration | 1 wk before systemic symptoms | Fever (63.08%), cough (60.00%), dyspnea (47.69%), sore throat, diarrhea (32.31%), chest pain (30.77%) |
6 | Biadsee et al. [13] | 2020 | Taste alteration (n=67), dry mouth (n=72), plaque-like changes in the tongue (n=9), swelling in the oral cavity (n=10) | Tongue, oral mucosa | Red and white lesions, taste alteration, xerostomia | Along with systemic symptoms | Cough and runny nose (p=0.018), olfactory dysfunction |
7 | Bodnia and Katzenstein [14] | 2020 | Total loss of taste (70%) | Tongue | Taste alteration | 1–3 wk (78%), 3–6 wk (22%) | Fatigue, headache, fever, dry cough, disturbance of the sense of smell |
8 | Chen et al. [15] | 2020 | Amblygeustia (47.2%), dry mouth (11.1%) | Tongue, oral mucosa | Taste alteration, xerostomia | Along with systemic symptoms | Submandibular lymph node enlargement (n=1), cough (n=21), fever (n=20), diarrhea (n=4), chest tightness (n=13) |
9 | Dell’Era et al. [16] | 2020 | Taste disorders (65.5%) | Tongue | Taste alteration | Mean duration, 10 d | Fever (72.1%), cough (47.9%), fatigue (40.3%), dyspnea (21.7%), diarrhea (19.7%) |
10 | Kumar et al. [17] | 2021 | Taste, dysfunction (28.4%) | Tongue | Taste alteration | Duration, 2–15 d | Malaise (14.2%), sore throat (19.9%), cough (20.6%), fever (48.2%), diarrhea (5.7%), nasal discharge (3.5%), headache (5.7%) |
11 | Lechien et al. [18] | 2020 | Gustatory dysfunction (88.8%) | Tongue | Taste alteration | Mean duration, 9.2±6.2 d | Olfactory dysfunction (85.6%) |
12 | Paderno et al. [19] | 2020 | Gustatory dysfunction (group A, 51.9%; group B, 78.9%); partial, 36.8%; total, 60.1%; unable to assess, 3.1% | Tongue | Taste alteration | First symptom in 11.9% (group A) and 10.2% (group B); mean duration, 9.2±5.4 | Olfactory dysfunction, fever, cough, headache, dyspnea, asthenia, diarrhea, nausea, nasal congestion, pharyngodynia |
13 | Boscolo-Rizzo et al. [20] | 2020 | Loss of taste (n=113) | Tongue | Taste alteration | Mean duration, 9.5 d | Dry cough, fever, headache, sore throat, chest pain, nausea, abdominal pain |
14 | Yan et al. [21] | 2020 | Gustatory impairment (71%) (p<0.001) | Tongue | Taste alteration | - | Fatigue (81%), fever (70%), anosmia (68%), myalgia or arthralgia (63%), diarrhea (48%), nausea (27%) |
15 | Sinjari et al. [22] | 2020 | Impaired taste (25%), burning sensation (15%), difficulty in swallowing (20%), dry mouth (30%) (p=0.02) | Oral mucosa, tongue | Redness and burning sensation, taste alteration, xerostomia | - | - |
16 | Giacomelli et al. [23] | 2020 | Dysgeusia (8.5%), ageusia (1.7%) | Tongue | Taste alteration | Before hospitalization (91%) | Fever (72.8%), cough (37.3%), dyspnea (25.4%), sore throat (1.7%), arthralgia (5.1%), headache (3.4%), asthenia (1.7%), abdominal symptoms (8.5%) |
17 | Mascitti et al. [24] | 2020 | Oral lichenoid reaction (32.5%), oral enanthema (27.5%), macroglossia (25.0%), cheilitis (12.5%), ageusia (20.5%), extensive ulcerations of the tongue (2.5%) | Lips, tongue, oral mucosa | Oral ulceration, vesiculobullous lesions. taste alteration | - | Macular exanthema (80%), face edema (32%), livedo (13%), urticarial rash (8%), purpura (5%), oral lichenoid lesions (33%), conjunctivitis (18%) |
18 | Salehi et al. [25] | 2020 | White plaques on the intraoral mucous layer of oral mucosa | Oral mucosa | Red and white lesions | - | - |
19 | Askin et al. [26] | 2020 | Aphthous stomatitis (5.8%), rash and erythema, aphthous lesion on side of tongue | Tongue, oral mucosa | Vesiculobullous lesions, redness and burning sensation | - | Cutaneous findings (36.1%) |
20 | Katz and Yue [27] | 2021 | Recurrent aphthous stomatitis (0.64%) | Oral mucosa | Oral ulceration | - | - |
21 | Fantozzi et al. [28] | 2020 | Dry mouth (45.9%), swallowing difficulties (39.2%), dysgeusia (59.5%) | Tongue, oral mucosa | Redness and burning sensation, oral ulceration, taste alteration, xerostomia | First symptom (xerostomia) (19.6%); dysgeusia (87.9%), duration (xerostomia), 7 d; dysgeusia 6 d | Fever (90.9%), cough (46.8%), dyspnea (34.3%), diarrhea (4.5%), sore throat (3.6%), fatigue (3.6%), myalgia/arthralgia (2.7%), vomiting (2.7%) |
22 | Favia et al. [29] | 2021 | Geographic tongue (n=7), fissured tongue (n=5), ulcerative lesion (n=65), blisters (n=19), hyperplasia of papillae (n=48), angina bullosa (n=11), candidiasis (n=28), ulceronecrotic gingivitis (n=7), petechiae (n=14), oral haemorrhage (n=1), taste disorders (90%) | Tongue, oral mucosa, lips | Red and white lesions, morphological changes of tongue, vesiculobullous lesions, oral ulceration, taste alteration | Together with general symptoms (26.2%); duration, 1 wk (41%); after 1 wk of general symptoms (32.6%) | Fever, anosmia, cough, sore throat, congestion, runny nose, nausea or vomiting, muscle and body aches, dermatologic manifestation, pneumonia, dyspnea, hypoxia (SpO2 <90%) |
23 | Halepas et al. 2021 [30] | 2021 | Red and/or swollen lips (48.9%), strawberry tongue (10.6%) | Lips, tongue | Redness and burning sensation, morphological changes of tongue | - | Fever |
24 | Rekhtman et al. [31] | 2021 | Rashes on lips and tongue (5.7% and 2.9%), ulcers on lips and tongue | Lips and tongue | Redness and burning sensation, oral ulceration | Generalized rashes | |
25 | Marouf et al. [32] | 2021 | Periodontitis (258/568) | Periodontium | Gingival and periodontal changes | - | - |
26 | Subramaniam et al. [33] | 2021 | Ulcers on oral mucosa; burning mouth and mucositis on lower labial mucosa, papillary atrophy; reddish-white spots on the palate; ulcers on lower lip; pallor of lip | Oral mucosa palate, lips, tongue | Oral ulceration, petechiae, redness and burning sensation, morphological changes of tongue | - | Fever, cough, dyspnea, runny nose, chest tightness, loss of smell |
27 | Abubakr et al. [34] | 2021 | Dental pain (23%), pain in jaw bones or joint (12.0%), halitosis (10.5%), ulcerations (20.4%), dry mouth (47.6%) | Oral mucosa | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, xerostomia | - | Fever, myalgia, dysphagia, and hyposmia, loss of smell, nasal itching |
28 | Song et al. [35] | 2021 | Loss of taste (20.6%) | Tongue | Taste alteration | First symptom (0.4%), recovery time, 7 d | Nasal obstruction (8.6%), rhinorrhea (10.3%), nasal itching (4.9%), sneezing (11.0%), loss of smell (11.4%) |
29 | Bardellini et al. [36] | 2021 | Oral pseudomembranous candidiasis (7.4%), geographic tongue (3.7%), coated tongue (7.4%), taste alteration (11.1%) | Tongue, oral mucosa | Red and white lesions, morphological changes of tongue, taste alteration | - | Fever, cough, rhinorrhoea, breathing difficulty |
30 | Gherlone et al. [37] | 2021 | Salivary gland ectasia (38%), dry mouth (30%), dysgeusia (17%), white plaque (28%), oral ulcers (12%) | Salivary glands, tongue, oral mucosa | Red and white lesions, oral ulceration, xerostomia, salivary gland disorder | - | - |
31 | El Kady et al. [38] | 2021 | Dry mouth (39.7%), loss of salt sensation (34.5%), loss of sweet sensation (29.3%), altered food taste (25.9%), tongue redness (8.8%), gingival bleeding (7%), salivary glands infection (22.4%), swellings in the salivary gland or cheek (13.8%), pain or swelling below mandible (10.8%), burning mouth sensation (22.4%), ulcers (17.2%) | Tongue, salivary glands, gingiva, oral mucosa | Redness and burning sensation, taste alteration, xerostomia, gingival and periodontal changes, salivary gland disorder | - | - |
32 | Fidan et al. [39] | 2021 | Aphthous-like ulcer (36.5%), erythema (25.7%), lichen planus (16.2%), tongue (31.8%), oral mucosa (27.0%), gingiva (18.9%), palate (5.4%) | Tongue (39.7%), oral mucosa (34.5%), gingiva (18.9%), palate (6.9%) | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, red and white lesions | Oral lesions prior COVID-19 diagnosis | - |
33 | Natto et al. [40] | 2021 | Loss of taste (43.4%), erythema/desquamated gingivitis and coated tongue (7.3%), ulcers/blisters (6.4%), pain and soreness (2.8%), dry mouth (0.9%) | Tongue, gingiva, oral mucosa | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, taste alteration, xerostomia, gingival changes | After systemic symptoms | Cough, fever, sore throat, runny nose, muscle pain, headaches, nausea, diarrhea |
34 | Elamrousy et al. [41] | 2021 | Oral ulcers (92.8%), dry mouth (84%), loss of taste (55%), hemorrhagic ulcers with crust on lips | Lip (42.3%), tongue (38.5%), labial mucosa (34.6%) | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, taste alteration, xerostomia | - | Asthenia (67.7%), breath problems (67.7%), cough (67.7%), fatigue (19.4%), abdominal symptoms (12.9%) |
35 | Bulut et al. [42] | 2021 | Taste loss (53%), halitosis (21%), oropharyngeal wound and pain (18%), pain in the chewing muscles (16%), gum bleeding (17.5%), dry mouth (38%, after recovery 12.0%), aphthous ulcer (14.5%), sensitivity and/or pain in teeth (12%), herpes labialis (8.5%), burning in the tongue (7.5%) | Tongue, gingiva, lips | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, taste alteration, xerostomia | - | Presence of symptoms (87.5%) |
36 | Naser et al. [43] | 2021 | Burning sensation (6%), numbness or tingling of the tongue (2%), white coat of the tongue, gingiva, palate (31.6%, 22.4%, 15.6%), loss of taste (79.5%), aphthous ulcers (24.8%), black discoloration of oral cavity, lips and tongue (4.7%, 6.8%), yellow coating on lips (5.3%) | Tongue, palate, lips, oral mucosa | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, red and white lesions, taste alteration | - | - |
37 | Muthyam et al. [44] | 2022 | Dry mouth (44%) followed by swallowing difficulty, mouth ulcerations, chewing problems, gum bleeding, and burning sensation, altered taste (72%); fissured tongue, halitosis, and loss of taste, 2% | Gums, tongue, oral mucosa | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, morphological changes of tongue, taste alteration, xerostomia | Altered taste lasted more than 1 wk (53%) | Weakness (8%), cough and cold (4%), body pain (2%) |
38 | Ganesan et al. [45] | 2022 | Gustatory disturbance (51.2%); dry mouth (28%); erythema, ulcers and depapillation of tongue (15.5%); A statistically significant correlation between oral manifestations and disease severity (p≤0.001). | Tongue, oral mucosa | Morphological changes of tongue, oral ulceration, taste alteration, xerostomia | - | - |
39 | El Tantawi et al. [46] | 2022 | Dry mouth (11.1% vs. 7.5%, p=0.009) and change in taste (11.5% vs. 2.7%, p<0.001) were greater in COVID-19 person; leukoplakia (4.6%); ulcers & hairy tongue (2.3%); gingival redness and burning sensation (13.1%) | Oral mucosa tongue, gingiva | Morphological changes of tongue, oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, taste alteration, xerostomia, gingival and periodontal changes | - | - |
40 | Soares et al. [47] | 2022 | Ulcerative lesions in the palate (57.1%), tongue (29%), lips or palate (14.3%) | Tongue, lips, palate | Oral ulceration | - | Anosmia, fever, headache |
41 | Tuter et al. [48] | 2022 | Dry mouth (44.2%), oral ulceration (22.4%), oral mucosa (15.2%), tongue (10.8%) | Tongue, oral mucosa | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation | - | - |
42 | Schwab et al. [49] | 2022 | Ageusia (11.0%); opportunistic oral infections such as pseudomembranous candidiasis and herpes simplex (4.5%) | Tongue | Red and white lesions/fungal, taste alteration, oral ulceration | - | Cough (72.7%), dyspnoea (63.0%), fever (53.9%), anosmia (14.3%) |
43 | Chawla et al. [50] | 2022 | Dry mouth (38%) (p=0.03), dysgeusia (32%) (p=0.04), vesiculobullous lesion (13%), oral ulcers (3.7%) | Oral mucosa tongue | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, vesiculobullous lesions, taste alteration, xerostomia | - | Cough (30%), sore throat (20%), shortness of breath (7%), running nose (11%) |
44 | Binmadi et al. [51] | 2022 | Taste disturbance (60%); dry mouth (42%); oral ulcerations (11%); gingivitis/petechiae/candidiasis (6%); necrotizing periodontal disease/vesiculobullous lesions/erythema migrans/geographic tongue (4%) | Gingiva, tongue, oral mucosa | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, vesiculobullous lesions, morphological changes of tongue, red and white lesions, taste alteration, xerostomia | Concurrently (47%), after the general symptoms (43%), before the general symptoms (9%) | Fever (95%), headache (65%), fatigue (65%), cough (63%), myalgia/arthralgia (53%), loss of smell (53%), sore throat (50%), shortness of breath or dyspnea (40%), nausea or vomiting (21%), diarrhea (15%) |
45 | Eduardo et al. [52] | 2022 | Saliva alterations (24.4%), dryness (9.9%), tongue coating (3%), sialorrhea (3.3%), petechiae (10.5%), oral bleeding (7.5%) | Oral mucosa tongue, salivary glands | Red and white lesions, redness and burning sensation, salivary gland disorder, xerostomia | - | - |
46 | Villarroel-Dorrego et al. [53] | 2022 | Hemorrhagic ulcerative lesions (7.3%), erythematous and pseudomembranous forms of candidiasis (12.7%), angular cheilitis (1.5%), total loss of taste (60%), burning mouth (36.4%), dry mouth (27.3%) | Tongue, lips, oral mucosa | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, red and white, lesions, xerostomia | - | - |
47 | Manifar et al. [54] | 2022 | Dry mouth (68.6%) (p<0.001), dysgeusia (51.4%) (p<0.001), hypogeusia (49.3%), halitosis (31.4%), metallic taste (29.3%) | Tongue, oral mucosa | Redness and burning sensation, taste alteration, xerostomia | - | Gastrointestinal symptoms, smell defects, asthma, skin rashes, cough, malaise, myalgia, anorexia, respiratory distress, olfactory dysfunction |
48 | Bhuyan et al. [55] | 2022 | Burning sensation (2.4%), dry mouth (2.4%), loss of taste (31%) (p<0.001), mouth ulcer (2.4%), bleeding gum (2.4%) | Oral mucosa gums, tongue | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, taste alteration, xerostomia, gingival changes | - | - |
49 | Brandao et al. [56] | 2021 | Multiple aphthous-like ulcers covered with mucopurulent membrane in the upper and lower lip mucosa and tongue (cases 1, 2, 4, 5); ulcers on tongue and hard palate (case 3); ulcers on tongue and ageusia (cases 6, 7, 8) | Lips, tongue, palate | Oral ulceration, taste alteration | 6–10 d | Chest tightness, fever, cough (cases 1, 5, 7, 8); cough, fever, dyspnea (cases 2, 6); abdominal distension, fever, mild dyspnea (cases 3, 4) |
50 | Cruz Tapia et al. [57] | 2020 | Bulla on the hard palate (×6 mm) (case 1); diffuse purple macule (×12 mm) and papule-plaque (×8 mm) on the left and right palatal mucosa (case 2); tongue enlargement (case 3); Burning mouth sensation and reddish macules on hard palate (case 4) | Palate, tongue | Redness and burning sensation, vesiculobullous lesions, morphological changes of tongue | Fever, myalgia, dysphagia, hyposmia | |
51 | Vaira et al. [58] | 2020 | Hypogeusia (33 cases); complete ageusia (1 case) | Tongue | Taste alteration | Fever, cough, nasal obstruction, sore throat, hyposmia, anosmia, pneumonia | |
52 | Martin Carreras-Presas et al. [59] | 2021 | Dysgeusia (case 1); multiple ulcers | Tongue, lips | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, vesiculobullous lesions, taste alteration, gingival changes | Along with systemic symptoms | Asthenia, hyposmia, enlargement of lymph nodes in the neck (cases 1, 3); fever, diarrhea (case 2) |
On palate (case 2); pain on tongue, blisters in lip mucosa and | |||||||
Desquamative gingivitis (case 3) | |||||||
53 | Rodriguez et al. [60] | 2022 | Dysgeusia, aphthous‐like lesions, burning sensation, and tongue depapillation (case 1); burning mouth sensation and unilateral commissural fissures (case 2); dry mouth, lesions on the tongue, palate, and commissure (case 3) | Tongue, palate, oral mucosa | Redness and burning sensation, morphological changes of tongue, taste alteration, xerostomia | Before presentation (case 1); after discharge (case 2); with systemic symptoms (case 3) | Fever, malaise, anosmia, diarrhea, pneumonia (cases 1, 3) |
54 | Corchuelo and Ulloa [61] | 2020 | Reddish plaques on the lower lip, dark brown pigmentation and aphthous ulcers in the gums, whitish area in tongue | Lower lips, gums | Oral ulceration, vesiculobullous lesions, red and white lesions | Mean duration, 8–10 d | - |
55 | Eghbali Zarch and Hosseinzadeh [62] | 2021 | Vesicles on lower lip mucosa | Lip | Vesiculobullous lesions | 2 d before systemic symptoms | High fever, fatigue, lack of appetite |
56 | Hjelmesaeth and Skaare [63] | 2020 | Total ageusia | Tongue | Taste alteration | - | - |
57 | Cebeci Kahraman and Caskurlu [64] | 2020 | Erythematous surface (hard palate), few petechiae in the midline and numerous pustular enanthema near the soft palate border | Palate | Red and white lesions, oral ulceration | Mean duration, 10 d | Sore throat; fever, fatigue, severe dry cough, inability to taste or smell |
58 | Smith et al. [65] | 2020 | Loss of taste | Tongue | Taste alteration | Before general symptoms | Frontal headache, loss of smell, headache, loose stools |
59 | Maniaci et al. [66] | 2020 | Transient loss of taste | Tongue | Taste alteration | Mean duration, 12 d | Fever, sore throat, runny nose, presence of erythematous skin lesions on the lower limbs, asthenia |
60 | Melley et al. [67] | 2020 | Loss of taste | Tongue | Taste alteration | 1 wk before systemic presentation | Shortness of breath, fatigue, loss of appetite |
61 | Riad et al. [68] | 2022 | Painful white patches on the dorsal surface of the tongue and palate, mild tongue pain | Tongue, palate | Red and white lesions | 2 wk before diagnosis | Sore throat, generalized myalgia, fatigue with intermittent fever |
62 | Putra et al. [69] | 2020 | Stomatitis aphthous | Oral mucosa | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation | Day 7 | Fever, back pain, myalgia, sore throat, dry cough, rhinorrhea, anosmia |
63 | Dalipi et al. [70] | 2021 | Loss of taste | Tongue, lips | Vesiculobullous lesions, taste alteration | Loss of taste, 2 wk before diagnosis | Fever, cough, headache, muscle pain, loss of smell, dark red, purpuric, irregular maculopapular lesions on abdomen |
Bullous and erosive erythematous lesions of lips and oral mucosa | |||||||
64 | Eita [71] | 2021 | Dysgeusia and greasy tongue coat | Tongue | Morphological changes of tongue, taste alteration | Before systemic symptoms | Sore throat, fever (38 °C), nasal congestion, conjunctivitis, nausea; abdominal pain, diarrhea, fatigue, severe joint pain |
65 | Cirillo and Colella [72] | 2021 | Loss of taste | Tongue | Taste alteration | 1 wk before presentation | Loss of smell, headache, fatigue, muscle pain |
66 | Nejabi et al. [73] | 2021 | Fissured tongue, white scars and painful erosive ulcer on the dorsal surface of the tongue | Tongue | Morphological changes of tongue, oral ulceration | After 1 wk of general symptoms | Fever, cough, taste alterations, olfactory dysfunction, chest tightness |
67 | Klein et al. [74] | 2021 | Loss of taste | Tongue | Taste alteration | From 4th to 6 wk | Fever, dry cough, chest pain, sore throat, diarrhea, nausea, headache, back pain |
68 | Ramires et al. [75] | 2021 | Crusted ulcers on lip vermilion (both upper and lower lips) | Lip | Oral ulceration | 2 wk after the onset of fever | Flu-like syndrome: severe and progressive dyspnea (SpO2=88%) |
69 | Hockova et al. [76] | 2021 | Oral lesions at the dorsal surface of the tongue (case 1); multiple lesions located on the tongue dorsum and labial mucosa (case 2); lesions on upper and lower lip (case 3) | Tongue, lips | Oral ulceration | After the diagnosis (all 3 cases) | Headache, fever, dry cough, dyspnoea |
70 | Teixeira et al. [77] | 2021 | Painful vesiculobullous lip lesions | Lips | Vesiculobullous lesions | After 4 d (case 1); after 10 d (case 2); after 11 d (case 3); after 19 d (case 4) | Headache, myalgia, dyspnea |
71 | Emelyanova et al. [78] | 2021 | Unusual tongue appearance and burning sensation, intermittent bleeding of gums, severe dryness in the oral cavity and persistent distortion of taste | Tongue, gums, oral mucosa | Redness and burning sensation, morphological changes of tongue, xerostomia | 3rd day (dysgeusia) and 5th day (xerostomia) after systemic symptoms | Rhinorrhea, coughing and increased body temperature to 38.5 °C |
72 | Fathi et al. [79] | 2021 | Oral pain, ulcerative lesions on oral mucosa, hemorrhagic crusts on lips | Oral mucosa, lips | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation | 3rd day (oral pain) | Fever, abdominal pain, nausea, occasional vomiting |
73 | Shenoy et al. [80] | 2022 | Ulcer with irregular borders on the dorsum of the tongue surrounded by a scrapable whitish plaque | Tongue | Oral ulceration, red and white lesions | Systemic symptoms, 3 wk prior | Fever, cough, chest tightness |
74 | Palaia et al. [81] | 2022 | Extensive erosions involving lips, ulcers on the hard palate, blisters and ulcers on the dorsal surface of the tongue cheek mucosa | Palate, lips, oral mucosa | Oral ulceration, vesiculobullous lesions, redness and burning sensation | 7 d prior to general symptoms (duration of oral lesions, 14 d) | Bilateral cutaneous lesions were also evident on the hands. Low-grade fever |
75 | Rafalowiczet al. [82] | 2022 | Unilateral aphthous-like lesions on the left side of the hard palate (case 1 & 5); hemorrhagic changes on the palate and cheilitis (case 2); smooth tongue with intensely red-purple mucosa (case 3); angioma-type lesion on the right side of the palate (case 4); mycosis of the tongue, extensive lesions on the palate, cheilitis (case 6) | Hard palate, tongue, lips | Oral ulceration, redness and burning sensation, red and white/fungal, morphological changes of tongue | - | Fever, malaise, taste disorders, anosmia, and pneumonia (case 1); dyspnea, persistent diarrhea, and vomiting (case 2); loss of smell and taste and fever for 9 d (cases 4, 5) |
76 | Jogdand et al. [83] | 2023 | Ulcers with yellowish gray pseudo-membrane on oral mucosa and palate | Oral mucosa, palate | Oral ulceration, red and white lesions | - | - |
77 | Mohammad et al. [84] | 2023 | Dry mouth (50%), gustatory dysfunction (37%), burning mouth sensation (22.5%), oral pain (17%), aphthous lesions, fissural cheilitis and tongue depapillation (9.5%), candidiasis (7.5%), gingival bleeding (2.5%) | Gingiva, oral mucosa, tongue | Oral ulceration, red and white lesions, morphological changes of tongue, taste alteration, xerostomia, gingival changes | - | Fever (83.5%), weakness (80%), myalgia (73%), headache (70%), cough (65%), loss of smell sensation (54%), loss of taste sensation (48.5%), sore throat (38.5%), nasal congestion (26.5%), runny nose (25%), gastrointestinal symptom (24.5%) |
78 | Al-Magsoosi et al. [85] | 2023 | Ageusia (66.8%), dry mouth (59%), gustatory changes (46%), dysphagia (40.5%), burning sensation (20.8%), oral ulceration (14.5%), gingival bleeding (3.3%) | Tongue, oral mucosa, gingiva | Redness and burning sensation, taste alteration, xerostomia | - | - |
79 | Cazzolla et al. [86] | 2023 | Taste dysfunction (208/25%) | Tongue | Taste alteration | 1 wk before general symptoms | Fever, breathing, asthenia, rhinorrhea, headache, abdominal symptoms, sore throat, chest pain, cough |
ICU, intensive care unit; M, male; F, female; DM, diabetes mellitus; CLD, chronic lung disease; CAD, coronary artery disease; COPD, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; GERD, gastroesophageal reflux disease; MI, myocardial infarction; -, not mentioned in article. Mean±standard deviation.
-, not mentioned in article.